I was beside myself with excitement over this release! It’s not that I was in any need of another highlighter; it was because it had been so long since the brand released a new product! I’ve been tempted so many times to buy the Color Fluids and Heroline Eyeliner, but with so many good affordable options in that product category, I couldn’t justify the prices. Regarding the Color Fluids specifically, the shades are liquid versions of what I already have in the Beautopsy palette, and powders are already the medium I use most.
An amazing highlighter though is something I can consider. Let’s see if it was worth it!

Hindash Gradient Highlighter in Peak Heat

What makes this product special, to start off with, is the hybrid gel-powder formula. Nearly all of my holy grail highlighters are baked gelee or gel-powder hybrid too. This helps it to look skin native while having a wetter looking shine on the skin.

The particles in this highlighter are very refined. I can wear this subtly or add more for extra intensity, particularly if I spray my face afterwards. However, how reflective it will look is largely dependent on the surrounding light. It will not look blinding without being directly hit, or at least not with this shade. As someone who prefers sheer to medium intensity, I’m perfectly content with not beaming!

I have no fading or longevity issues with the highlighter. The only thing to note is that it works perfectly fine over foundation, but it doesn’t adhere as well on my bare dry skin. So, adding anything moisturizing to my cheekbones on a low makeup day will help it stay on.

It’s easy to say this is an amazing product, but I wanted to be sure that it wasn’t a recency bias. So, over the course of a few weeks, I started analyzing my powder highlighter collection all over again!

The Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Multi-Glow in Dream Light has prettiest subtle glow, but it can be built up more intensely. It’s the friendliest on texture. It has ultra refined shimmer (except strip #2). The strips give me the ability to customize the color (although I don’t use #2 because of the larger sparkles). One negative is that it can look powdery, so using less is more. As long as I avoid trying to build up too much intensity, it is gorgeous.

The r.e.m. beauty Interstellar Highlighter Topper is super smooth, but shows the tiniest bit more particles compared to CT’s Dream Light, and it has more base color which means there’s a higher chance of it being harder to color match depending on the time of year. So, getting the right color is that much more important. That’s why my other shade (Miss Saturn) was good enough for the top favorites, but didn’t rank as high as Miss Mars because the color was off. Compared to many other highlighters I’ve owned, I still consider this to have a semi-sheer base enough to be a great “filler” highlighter to apply on top of scattered sparkles types of highlighters without increasing the intensity. This is slightly more reflective than CT’s Dream Light though.

Hindash’s highlighter is smoother than r.e.m beauty, but I can see it on the skin more than CT’s Dream Light only because the hybrid gel formula looks wetter, which is naturally more apparent. This can make it rank better or worse to me depending on my mood. When I do want more bling, Hindash’s can be sprayed to look even better, but CT’s doesn’t have the proportional improvement. It still looks great, but there’s only a minor difference. So Hindash’s is better at being intensified than CT Dream Light. These are the tiniest nitpicks! All of them are fantastic products!

Tom Ford’s Shade and Illuminate Highlighting Duo is the most reflective of the Top 5 and intense, so that can sometimes be great or not so great. The darker color is smoother. The lighter one has some slightly larger sparkles, which is why it dropped below Hindash in the ratings. It being hard pressed makes picking it up with certain brushes more challenging. Having the custom color is a good thing, though I’m forced to use the lighter color if I’m my winter shade, which might make the overall look have more obvious sparkle.

Charlotte Tilbury Hollywood Glow Glide Face Architect Highlighter is the wettest powder highlighter in my collection, but it has a strong base color. I used to consider this better than Dream Light because of the wet effect and reflectivity. Swatching them side by side, the Glow Glide looks more impressive. So how did it drop this far down? The base color strength. I said in my original review how important getting a matching color is for this formula to look good and not textured. Over time, I got lighter, so I started using Dream Light more, to the point where it became my number 1! In revisiting this Glow Glide, it looks gorgeous again because I’m back to being a little darker from the summertime.

The Gxve Beauty Highlighter is thinner than TF’s, and so the customizable color makes it the best color match within the top 10. It’s smooth, but others are smoother. It’s more reflective than the top 3, but also has slightly more noticeable shimmer particles. The scent is strong! It has the same drawback as CT Dream Light, that it can look slightly powdery on my dry skin if overapplied. I always do a subtle layer to avoid an intense bling anyway, so I don’t usually have this problem.

PML’s Divine Rose Highlighter is thin like Gxve and smooth in texture, but the shimmer reflectivity is more intense, which makes the particles more apparent than the ones ranked higher. I wish the brand made a deeper color in this formula because it’s a little pearly despite the gold color. It had the potential to tie with Tom Ford, if not for the color, since they have similar texture, finish, and intensity.

Dior’s Highlighter has the thinnest texture with a deep yet translucent base, but the shimmer color itself is too light for me right now. The shimmer is so refined and the formula is so smooth. It would be absolutely amazing if I could get a less pearly shimmer shade!

So, that’s the Top 8 powder highlighters re-ranked!

Below is the ranking list from highest to lowest of the holy grail highlighters I brought with me compared to all the individual highlighters or from duos that I bought in 2024. This is not a complete ranking of my entire highlighter collection though because I have plenty of highlighters still in the US that would have placed between the Hatice Schmidt one and Fenty’s, such as Becca Cosmetics Highlighters, Persona Del Mar Cali Glow Highlighter, MAC Extra Dimension Skinfinish Highlighters, Colourpop Supershocks, Melt Digital Dust Highlighters, etc. Even my nine year old version of Guerlain Meteorites would have ranked higher than the version I have with me currently.

1. Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Multi-Glow
2. r.e.m. beauty Interstellar Highlighter Topper
3. Hindash Gradient Highlighter
4. Tom Ford’s Shade and Illuminate Highlighting Duo
5. Charlotte Tilbury Hollywood Glow Glide Face Architect Highlighter
6. Gxve Beauty Highlighter
7. Charlotte Tilbury Unreal Skin Sheer Glow Tint Hydrating Foundation Stick
8. Pat McGrath Divine Rose Skin Fetish Ultra Glow Highlighter
9. Highlighter from the Dior Rouge Contour & Glow Palette
10. Chantecaille Sunbeam Cheek and Eye Shade
11. Hatice Schmidt Highlighter
12. Fenty Demi’Glow Light-Diffusing Highlighter
13. Natasha Denona Hy-Gen Skincare Infused Glow Beautifier
14. Gucci Beauty Glow Highlighter
15. Highlighter from the MAC Golden Hour Glow Face Palette
16. Guerlain Météorites Light Revealing Pearls of Powder

The only highlighters I purchased in 2024 that are worth buying, because they topped my original list, are from Hindash and Dior. I’ve said before that I don’t need more highlighters, but this truly hammers this idea home.

That’s everything for today! Thanks for reading!

-Lili ❤