Chanel Les 4 Ombres Boutons Review and Comparison

From left to right: Chanel Tweed Cuivre, Guerlain Royal Jungle, YSL Over Brun, and Chanel Boutons Couture.

It is very unusual for me to want a purely neutral quad, but the photo above shows that it’s not impossible to draw me in. I knew I didn’t need this newest addition, and I had an entire month to try to talk myself out of buying it after seeing the sneak peeks on Instagram, but I couldn’t help it.

Les 4 Ombres Boutons Eyeshadow Palette in 219 Boutons Couture

The compact is typical for Chanel, but the embossing on the shadows, the gorgeous chocolatey shades, and the pattern on the velvet dust cover sleeve are such alluring qualities!

As someone with brown skin, the thought crossed my mind that these shades might not look distinctly different enough on my eyes. I grew excited when I swatched each color on my arm, and felt hopeful as I put each shade solo on my lids. I can clearly tell them apart when used separately. However, when building an eye look, the end result of using all four shades together is that it looks like one single eyeshadow. That’s how much the colors blend into one another, making it wasted effort. I can’t speak for anyone else, but on me, using 1-3 shades actually allows me to have more variety in the eyeshadow looks I create.

Lisa Eldridge Liquid Silk in Phoebe was used as the eye base for all looks in this post.

I’m content with the pigment level of the darkest three eyeshadows, but the beige shade (Shade 2) is practically the same color as my eye base. It’s too gently pigmented to show up easily on my eyes, and it makes the bare minimum of impact if used to highlight the center of the lid. Wetting my brush does not intensify it. It makes for a nice color to soften edges at least.

Shade 4 is a mauve-taupe that has the most shimmer of the four, and it adds a pretty gleam to the lids. I consider it to be an intense satin though. Applying this shade with a wet brush helps to pack more color onto the lids, increasing the opacity level. So, it ends up looking a tiny bit shinier, but I imagine most people don’t consider it worth the effort for a minuscule difference.
Perhaps Chanel doesn’t consider impactful shimmers to be “Couture.”

Shade 1 is a warm satin, whereas Shade 2 is darker, cooler toned, and more matte.

In terms of performance, the longevity is there. I don’t get fading or creasing. I can pick up a good amount of eyeshadow with my natural hair brushes, but the eye look will be visible yet soft on that first application. If I want to speed up the process of building maximum pigmentation, using my fingers is an easy way to do that. The sponge tip applicator housed in the compact works well for that task too.

01 Tweed Cuivre is the first and only other Chanel quad I own. In side-by-side swatches, it is so apparent to me why I think so highly of Tweed Cuivre, as it is much closer to my eyeshadow preferences. Tweed Cuivre is my version of “subtle glam,” yet it still has way more oomph compared to Boutons Couture.

Since these two are my only experiences interacting with Chanel eyeshadows, I can’t say whether or not they’re worth the upcharge compared to the permanent line. From photos alone, so many of the Chanel quads’ eyeshadows look like dusty baked domes. Swatches often looked chalky, thin, and lacking in pigment. I couldn’t understand why the brand’s eyeshadows continued to be popular and thought Tweed Cuivre was the exception. If Boutons Couture had a little more bling and the light shade was more opaque, I think I’d be more interested in exploring the brand.

These eyeshadows turned out to be much softer in texture than I expected (Tweed Cuivre is creamier though). This makes it easier to use than the original Guerlain Ombres G line, but I still very much prefer the YSL formula, which happens to be less money as well (especially in Europe).
That being said, I still like this quad. I would have liked to be strong enough to resist the marketing, especially with the number of influencers stating how limited this collection would be and the sharing of exclusive links to pre-order. I admittedly got caught up in the hype and there was the fear of missing out.
I don’t know how many units were divvied up across the world, but every quad is still available in Germany at the time of me writing this. I heard it sold out within days on the US website though.

At this point in time, I still don’t regret buying it, even if I acknowledge that I could have managed without it.

I don’t intend to give a full review of the Chanel Noir Allure Mascara sample that I got with my order. However, I wanted to point out that I’m wearing it in the three eyeshadow demos and full face photo. I like the length it provides, but the formula is so susceptible to water. If my eyes got watery at any point in the day, the mascara easily transferred onto my fingers while I tried to wipe my lashes. Another time, the mascara dripped into my actual eyeballs. I’m not surprised that a non-waterproof mascara would run, but this is the runniest I’ve ever experienced.

Going back to the topic of the Boutons collection, I think the 239 Boutons Baroque Quad is extremely eye-catching. I’m drawn to the colors, but I’m not confident that I would be happy enough with the shades on my eyes if I tried to use them all together. One review that made me content with my decision to ultimately skip buying this quad is from Nikki. One review that made me reconsider my decision is by Lauren on YouTube. I will continue to stay strong and resist though! One palette from this collection is enough.

Also, in order to keep the embossing around for as long as possible, I have only dipped into the right halves of the shades. This is how it looks after just five days.

That’s all for this week! I had to push back some pre-scheduled posts in order to get this review out as fast as possible, especially given the apparent limited quantities of this collection. The next few posts should be featuring products I’ve used for a lot longer.

-Lili

Was the Chanel Les Beiges Trio Worth Getting?

The compact photo above is better at showing the depth level, but the compact photo below is more accurate to the undertones.

I have more than enough makeup for one person, even though I currently only have access to about a quarter of my collection. For that reason, I tried my hardest to not be tempted into buying this Chanel product. I love their blushes, but I don’t use them enough. I have heard fantastic things about their highlighters, but most are too light for me (and the one I bought wasn’t as refined as I expected). I don’t own any bronzers from the brand, so that would be a new experience.

I watched a video from French for a Day to talk myself down from Chanel products in general, but even she seemed excited for the trio. It was ultimately the assurance that this would work on my skin tone from watching the video from I Am Jamila that kept me interested in this product. In addition, so many people I follow on YouTube and Instagram continued to rave about it even beyond the initial release, indicating that it’s not just temporary hype. The final nudge I needed was a small discount from the retailer Parfümerie Pieper, and I was sold!

Chanel Les Beiges Poudre Belle Mine Ensoleilleé in Deep Rose Gold

The blush is nice. It’s not difficult to nail a blush formula though, so I expected it would be good. It’s not my favorite tone of pink, but it’s pretty. For those that have the Guerlain Terracotta blush in Deep Nude, this is basically the same color.

The bronzer is also pretty good. If you’ve seen my ranking of bronzers that I purchased in 2023 exclusively, I would say it performs as well as MAC’s Sunstruck bronzers, Pat Mcgrath’s Divine Powder bronzers, and perhaps even Nars Laguna Talc-Free Bronzing Powders. This means that it’s among bronzers I like a lot, but not quite enough to make the top 10. I didn’t watch French for a Day’s actual review of the trios until I finished my first draft of this post, and in her opinion the powders are average quality for Chanel. That doesn’t make them bad, just not the best that the brand is capable of producing. I felt strangely reassured when hearing this because it matched my feelings, after using this product for a while, that perhaps this being called “phenomenal” is an over-exaggeration.

I had mixed feelings about the highlighter initially. I love a subtle highlighter, but this is too subtle for me to want to use alone. It’s along the same vein of the Guerlain Météorites, but even less shimmery. I built it up as much as I could in the photos above.
What made me start to like this highlighter is that it offers something I don’t have in my collection, which is the ability to turn the bronzer and/or blush into a glowy one without changing the color or making it overly shimmery. It lightens the color, but not by much. I have a few products that I mix with others to achieve this effect, but they are pigmented products that will alter the final color by adding more of a brown tone, warmth or make it cooler toned, etc. This one is sheer enough to transform other products too. In practical usage, I don’t know how often I would pair this with other products besides the ones in this compact, but the option is there.

In the previous photos, I was wearing the Lisa Eldridge Foundation which is a little dark and leans orange on me. In the photo with the blue shirt above, I’m wearing a combination of the Givenchy and Armani foundations, which are a better match (and it’s also a slightly sunnier day, so this is why I look a bit lighter). As for the Chanel products, I wore the amount I normally would, rather than building it up for photos, like the previous ones. The sheerer application of blush with the highlighter on top accounts for the depth differences in the photos.

I have no issues with fading or longevity with this product. These aren’t the smoothest powders I’ve used, but they blend pretty well, especially with a fox or saikoho goat brush. I also have some smaller sized brushes that can fit well in the compact, so it isn’t too much of a hassle having all three colors that close together. A tip I learned for getting into the blush easier is to turn the compact 180 degrees so that it’s the top stripe and the highlighter is on the bottom instead. Then I can dip the angled part of my brush into the blush and can see what I’m doing from top to bottom rather than trying to avoid the brush getting into the bronzer while having the back of the brush hitting the edge of the compact.

Sometimes luxury products look pretty, but don’t feel luxurious. This does feel like a luxury product in the hand, and because the retailer I purchased from included a few Chanel samples, just like the official Chanel website does, I still had the luxury experience.

Having three products in one feels like the pricing is appropriate, especially for a brand like Chanel. I posed the question in the title as to whether this was worth me buying. Considering the discounted price I paid, I think it technically was. However, from a personal standpoint looking at all the makeup I own and factoring in how often I’ll use this palette, perhaps it wasn’t. Time will tell, but for now, I am happy I made this purchase.

DISCLOSURE: I posted several links, including the retailer, but they are normal links, not affiliate links. I paid for these myself and these opinions are my own. At this time, I have no personal or professional connections to the companies or influencers mentioned.

Thank you for reading! I hope it has been helpful.

-Lili